Par Patrick Prézeau Stephenson
In the context of the pressing political and socio-economic challenges facing Haiti, the selection of a Prime Minister by the Presidential Transitional Council (PTC) is a crucial task. To our knowledge, as of May 24, 2024, no women have been included in the shortlist of five candidates, although some have presented compelling profiles for the position. This essay evaluates the strengths and weaknesses of the five candidates preselected for the post of Prime Minister, based on the list published in a tweet from Le Nouvelliste and biographical summaries of the candidates obtained online[1].
Fritz Belizaire
Forces:
Political Experience: Fritz Bélizaire served as Minister of Youth and Sports from 2006 to 2011 under the presidency of René Préval, demonstrating his ability to manage government portfolios and navigate the political landscape. Expertise Technique: As a civil engineer, he brings valuable technical expertise in infrastructure, essential for Haiti’s development. Reconnaissance: Its nomination by four of the seven CPT parties indicates a certain level of recognition and political support, which may facilitate consensus building within the government. Weaknesses:
Contested Nomination: The fact that his appointment was contested within the council suggests potential political divisions and a lack of unanimous support, which could undermine his effectiveness. Limited National Visibility: The recent absence of prominent national positions could affect its public visibility and ability to gain broad support. Gary Conille
Forces:
International Experience: His work with the United Nations and his academic background provide him with valuable perspectives on international development and diplomatic relations. Prime Minister experience: His tenure as former Prime Minister gives him an understanding of the demands and responsibilities of the role, an asset in navigating the complexities of Haitian politics. Weaknesses:
Short and Controversial Mandate: His brief tenure as prime minister, ended amid political controversy and rumors of corruption, could damage his credibility and effectiveness. Potential Distrust: The lack of audit of his tenure and unresolved corruption allegations may lead to distrust among his political peers and the public. Paul Antoine Bien-Aimé
Forces:
Ministerial Experience: His experience as Minister of the Interior and Territorial Communities shows his ability to manage internal affairs and local governance. Stability in Governance: Maintaining his position through different administrations indicates a certain stability and reliability in his leadership. Weaknesses:
Limited Sector Focus: Although he is experienced in domestic affairs, his expertise may be limited to that sector, potentially restricting his ability to address other critical areas like economic development and foreign policy. Political Legacy: As a long-serving political figure, he might be associated with the existing political establishment, a disadvantage in a climate where there is a demand for fresh leadership. Alix Didier Fils-Aimé
Forces:
Private Sector Expertise: His appointment by AmCham and his business background highlight his abilities in economic management and development, crucial for Haiti’s growth. Political Candidacy: His experience as a former Senate candidate shows his political ambition and familiarity with the electoral process. Weaknesses:
Lack of Government Experience: Primarily experienced in the private sector, he has less exposure to government operations and public administration. Potential Bias: Its close ties to the private sector can lead to perceptions of bias in favor of commercial interests at the expense of broader public needs. Jean Rodolphe Joazil
Forces:
Defense Expertise: His role as Minister of Defense and his military background provide him with crucial security and defense skills, essential to addressing Haiti’s security challenges. Integrity and Discipline: His military service suggests a high level of discipline and integrity, valuable traits for a national leader. Weaknesses:
Narrow Focus: His expertise is primarily in defense and security, which may not fully prepare him to address the wide range of socio-economic issues facing Haiti. Limited Political Experience: Although he is experienced on defense, Joazil has limited exposure to broader political leadership roles, which could be a disadvantage in navigating the political landscape. Summary Table using the Key Strategic Assessment (KSA)
CriteriaFritz BelizaireGary ConillePaul Antoine Bien-AiméAlix Didier Fils-AiméJean Rodolphe JoazilSKILLSLeadership and ManagementExperience in government portfolio managementFormer PM, international developmentExtensive ministerial experienceBusiness management, political candidacyDefense and security managementDecision Making and Problem SolvingDemonstrated in previous ministerial rolesProven but controversial PM tenureProven in the management of internal affairsDemonstrated in business managementProven in military decisionsCommunication and NegotiationEffective in political rolesExcellent with international organizationsEffective in local governanceEffective in business environmentsEffective in the military and defense sectorsKnowledgeUnderstanding of GovernanceIn-depth knowledge of various ministerial rolesIn-depth understanding of roles at the UN and as PMExtensive knowledge of domestic governanceKnowledge of business and political processesKnowledge of defense governanceFamiliarity with National and International IssuesKnowledge of national political rolesExtensive national and international experienceKnowledge of national issuesKnowledge of economic developmentKnowledge of national security issuesKnowledge of the April 3 AgreementProbably aware, but less emphasized in biographyWell informedProbably aware through ministerial rolesIn the know through political engagementProbably aware, but less emphasized in biographyExperienceRelevant Professional ContextMinisterial roles, civil engineerFormer PM, UN positionsMinister of the InteriorExperience in business and politicsMinister of Defense, military officerCrisis managementProven in infrastructure and youth crisesProven but controversialProven in domestic crisis managementDemonstrated in crisis management in businessProven in military and defense crisesPublic Service and Community EngagementDemonstrated in various ministerial rolesLong history in public serviceLong history in public serviceActive in business and political spheresDemonstrated in defense and public safety Conclusion
Each candidate brings a unique set of strengths and weaknesses. Fritz Bélizaire offers political and technical expertise but faces contested support. Gary Conille has valuable international experience but is marred by past controversies. Paul Antoine Bien-Aimé brings stability but may lack broader sector experience. Alix Didier Fils-Aimé brings economic perspectives but lacks government experience. Jean Rodolphe Joazil offers strong defensive skills but has a narrow focus on security.
The CPT must carefully weigh these factors to select a prime minister who can meet Haiti’s urgent needs and guide the country toward stability and credible elections.
References
[1] Tweet from Le Nouvelliste announcing the 5 candidates retained according to a member of the Presidential Transitional Council Le Nouvelliste
@nouvelliste, 7:00 PM · May 24, 2024
Short list of 5 candidates for the post of Prime Minister: Fritz Bélizaire, Gary Conille, Paul Antoine Bien-Aimé, Alix Didier Fils-Aimé and Jean Rodolphe Joazil. The list went from 68 to 23 candidates then to 13 and to 5 today, according to a member of the Presidential Council at…
— Le Nouvelliste (@nouvelliste) May 24, 2024 Contact Media Patrick Prézeau Stephenson: Editor [email protected]
But many loads are not heavy. Thanks for sharing the manifesto:
Visit the home page: https://shorturl.at/cozFM
Read online: https://shorturl.at/rBOTZ
Download: https://shorturl.at/zIR29
